zor – a re-review

Starring

Jeet, Varsha, Dipankar De, Anamika Saha and Subrata Dutta (Mumbai)

Story and Screenplay

Manjil Banerjee

Cinematography

B Satish

Music

SK Venkatesh

Production Company

T Sarkar Productions

Produced by

Mrs Mukul Sarkar

Directed by

Swapan Saha

Synopsis:

Surjo (Jeet) is a brave, good and honest boy living with his middle-class parents and little sister. He is also a champion sprinter who bags trophies in every sprinting event. His life takes a 180-degree turn when he goes to Siliguri to take part in a sprint championship. There, he is shocked to discover that Sumi (Varsha), a local girl, is being tortured and taken away against her wishes by the goons of the local mafia lord, Indrajeet (Subrata Dutta), with his mother Mahamaya Sen’s (Anamika Saha) backing. Surjo rescues the girl from their clutches and drives away with her to Kolkata in Indrajeet’s own vehicle. He hides her in his house without his parents getting wise to her presence while Indrajeet files a kidnapping complaint against Surjo. Sumi’s mother and brother have already directed her to fly away to her US-based uncle to get away from Indrajeet. Surjo’s aim now is to see Sumi fly off to the US and he arranges her visa and ticket with the help of his friends. When his parents learn of the stowaway hiding in their own home, they join forces, as Indrajeet, his mother and their goons get hot on the chase. Just as Sumi steps into the airport to catch her flight, Surjo realises that he has fallen in love with the girl and the two ride back into town only this time, for Surjo’s kid sister to be kidnapped by Indrajeet. After lots of fisticuffs in Indrajeet’s suburban bungalow to rescue Surjo’s kidnapped sister, Indrajeet is accidentally shot and killed by a bullet his mother aimed at Surjo. She dies of shock. The film closes on the familiar image of the group photograph with the implicit understanding that Surjo and Sumi will live happily ever after.

Is there a measuring rod to evaluate a film? Is there a value system that distinguishes a good film from a bad film? Or are these man-made categories that are relative to person, time and place? Swapan Saha is known as a quickie director in Tollygunge who completes a film in 20 days flat and has an average release rate of one film per month. He does not care about press previews and is not interested in a PR machine. He generally backs out of interviews because he knows critics look down on him as a director of ‘quack’ and quickie films. So, the critic who is thrust with the job of reviewing a Swapan Saha film has often to buy the ticket himself.

When the critic buys his ticket with his own money, he watches the film with the full house a Swapan Saha film commands. And his views are prone to be influenced by the constant chain of cat-calls, whistles, ceetees, loud cheering and clapping every time the hero, be it Jeet or Prasenjeet or Mithun, appears on screen. This is exactly what happened to this critic. The hall was packed to capacity. It was amazing to discover how deeply the audience got involved in the goings-on as Jeet strutted about in slow motion across the screen in a panning shot, or, unclenched a fist till, caught in close-up, one could actually see blood flowing through the veins down the back of his palm when he readied to give it good to the wrong man at the right place and the right time.

For once, Saha gives us a good-hearted hero who has common traits of downing a beer or two with his cronies at an adda and lying through his teeth when he has to. For once, it is both hilarious and good to discover a marriage registrar persuading an eloping daughter to think twice before jumping. For once, one encounters a good hero who is not interested in a government job his father urges him to do. For once, one gets the chance of looking into the mind of a murderous, gun-happy, schizophrenic villain go weak-kneed and soft the minute he sets eyes on the girl of his dreams.

The song-dance numbers are ridiculous. Saha does not care one bit about the crowds gathered to watch location shootings. Nor does he care to smother the endless tears of Surjo’s mother or stop the sweet-and-naughty kid sister act done to death in the film. Indrajeet slaughters Sumi’s widowed mother and older brother in cold blood but Sumi does not seem to know or care. But these are points of pure logic, which you must leave outside the theatre before you step in. Saha needs to be lauded for keeping away from sex, sexual innuendo, rape attempts, bawdy humour and item numbers. Because he still manages to reach his audience, from frontbenchers to balcony-frequenters and the ones in the middle. For a Swapan Saha film, the audience sets an example in classless democracy where the frontbenchers vie with the balcony-hoppers in sending out those loud whistles and louder claps. There is plenty of blood and gore though but they are well-placed and orchestrated to suit the plot of the film

Subrata Dutta is slick in his villainy and completely credible in his weak-kneed act. Jeet as Surjo has built up his muscles to suit those scenes of unclenched fists and his song-dance acts have gone up by notches. The action scenes are well choreographed and convincing. Intimate love scenes still however remain Jeet’s weak point. Varsha as Sumi needs to perfect her diction but otherwise is ok. For a change, Dipankar De has a positive role and he does it brilliantly with the right touch of wry humour, satire, and honesty. Anamika Saha as Mahamaya Sen has stripped herself of much melodrama to convince in a different role. The cinematography is rather uneven, flat in the indoor shots but beautiful in the outdoor ones especially the picturesque hills capes of North Bengal. Venkatesh’s music is nothing to cheer about and the songs are neither well placed nor well choreographed. The Bengali diction by the male singers is plain atrocious. The song-dance numbers have been put in for sheer box office value.

But then, the entire film is targeted solely at the box office and not at awards or film festivals. So, what, pray, is a good film? A film that gets back the money the producers have invested in it several times over? Or, a film that wins accolades at film festivals and awards on different platforms but fails to pull in an audience? Zor taught this critic one good lesson – that the power of the audience is stronger and greater than the power of the pen; that once in a while, the critic needs to step down from that ivory tower of snobbish criticism he/she feels is ‘intellectual’ and watch a film with the ones it has been made for – the audience.

Shoma A Chatterji is a freelance journalist who specialises in cinema and gender. She has won the National Award for Best Writing on Cinema twice.

Site developed by



dreamscape.co.in
Google
Web upperstall.com