myUpperstall   :   About   :   Wallpapers   
New to Upperstall? Join Now | Sign In
6568 films, 8314 profiles, and counting

  • films
  • people
  • blogs
FOLLOW US ON

 Ratings
OVERALL
73.00%
YOUR RATING
73.00% 
 contents
Photos

Upperstall Review


  
Maqbool

 

Hindi, 2004




At last! Vishal Bhardwaj's take off on Macbeth and The Godfather, Maqbool, shows that a good, sensible film can indeed be made within Hindi commercial cinema parameters. Setting Macbeth in Mumbai's underworld, Bhardwaj comes up with a gritty, dark tale of Maqbool, the right hand man of Abbaji, destroyed by his ambition for power and involvement with a woman- his boss's mistress Nimmi, that he could well have done better without. The film, aided by its well-written dialogues and superb performances, mark Vishal Bhardwaj as a director to watch out for.

Bhardwaj does an inspired adaptation of Macbeth - adding in desire for a femme fatale as well rather than just sticking to the power games of the underworld. He artfully combines the mediums of theatre and cinema in his treatment of the film. The casting of Naseeruddin Shah and Om Puri as two corrupt cops on Abbaji's payroll as the 'witches' of Macbeth works brilliantly - in particular Om Puri with his various prophesies. Sequences like Nimmi's final breakdown with Maqbool, the killing of Abbaji, the development of the affair of Maqbool and Nimmi are all handled extremely well.

Yes, there are snags - The film takes its time to settle down as the various characters are established haphazardly thereby often confusing the viewer. There is too little shown of the dynamism of Maqbool, which has supposedly made him Abbaji's right hand man. You see a detached man from the rest bothered about his work but not really him in action. So you wonder why is it that Abbaji singles him out as his right hand and not anyone else. The tracks with the upright cop who is transferred to customs and with the Hindi film starlet are handled quite clumsily. While there is a build up of sorts to Maqbool's character leading to his hallucinations, Nimmi's bloody delusions comes out of the blue as if remember, we have to bring in this aspect of Lady Macbeth also. Also the film is too Urdu dialogue heavy at times alienating itself from the normal viewer. Technically too the film could have tighter and appears a tad too long but the acting more than makes up for it.

In fact, the performances in the film are extraordinary. Om Puri and Naseeruddin Shah reaffirm what fine artistes they are. Both are spot on with their sense of wry humour. Pankaj Kapoor as Abbaji successfully creates a Brandoesque Dawood. Finally getting a role of his calibre, he is brilliant as the short-statured, potbellied, shuffle-footed deadpan dialogue delivering Abbaji. Irrfan gives perhaps his best performance to date as the title character. Watch him as from being Abbaji's loyal servant for whom he would gladly give his life, he takes charge of the film once he falls prey to greed and lust and then see his resignation as he sees his empire around him crumble in the anguish through his eyes. Tabu is as good as ever. Be it her flirtatious scenes with Maqbool earlier on in the film, her enticing him to kill Abbaji and thus free herself from the old man or then her guilt over Abbaji's killing and subsequent descent into madness, she captures every nuance of her character. In the midst of such performances, Ajay Gehi and Masumi are at best adequate.

All in all a fine effort by Vishal Bhardwaj and certainly the best Hindi film in a long, long time.


Upperstall review by: TheThirdMan




  • Comments
  • News
  • TheThirdMan on One-on-one with Suriya:
    Thanks everyone for your comments. @Akash: High time for Suriya the actor to choose his films now
  • Tamilboy on One-on-one with Suriya:
    Ahhh Karan, this is a great read man! I have had the privilege of being in the same school and cl
  • Anand Subramanian on One-on-one with Suriya:
    Insightful indeed ! Karan has the ability to dig deeper to reveal small details that make his writin
  • Ronnie on One-on-one with Suriya:
    He has a down to earth charming quality about him that's infectious. Good introductory piece on him,
  • Banno on One-on-one with Suriya:
    For someone who doesn't know Tamil cinema or Suriya at all, this is a really good introduction. I li

 



Recent
  • Reviews
  • Films
  • People
  • Blogs
Right Yaaa Wrong
Practically nothing is right and plenty wrong in this tacky, inept thriller that was shot way back in 2007 but has manag...
Hide & Seek
What is it about thrillers, suspense films, murder mysteries, and whodunits that keeps filmmakers trying their luck with...
Road, Movie
At least Abhay Deol reaches his destination finally in Road, Movie. Wish one could say the same about the film....
Vel
Vel is Suriya's second film with Hari after Aaru (2005)...
Hide & Seek
What is it about thrillers, suspense films, murder mysteries, and whodunits that keeps filmmakers trying their luck with...
Right Yaaa Wrong
Practically nothing is right and plenty wrong in this tacky, inept thriller that was shot way back in 2007 but has manag...
Bina Rai
Even though Madhubala is considered the most beautiful Hindi film heroine ever, actress Shyama rev...
Ajay Devgan
From being dismissed as a non-looker who was adept only in action, Ajay Devgan has proved that he ...
Vikram
'Chiyaan' Vikram is one of the finest actors in mainstream Tamil cinema today as his superlative p...

popular

film releases